> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.crestingchronicle.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Andrew Jackson Downing and the Gothic Revival Cottage: When a Flirtation Is Not a Proposal
- URL: https://www.crestingchronicle.com/gothic-revival-cottage-downing-carpenter-gothic/
- Published: 2026-11-08T16:43:43.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-17T21:54:27.000Z
- Description: Two gentlemen with a fondness for the country house dressed rural America in pointed arches. Their story, and why a Gothic touch or two is a flirtation, not a proposal.
- Author: Lady Margaret Thornbury
- Tags: The Miscellany, Gothic Revival, #tip-article

Dearest reader, two gentlemen with a fondness for the country house did a great deal to dress rural America in pointed arches. Here is their story, followed by a word of caution about the many houses that only flirt with their style.

## Mr Downing and Mr Davis

The Gothic Revival style was promoted by Andrew Jackson Downing and Alexander Jackson Davis, especially for rural houses, the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission records. Downing's pattern books were busy things. They also promoted the Swiss Chalet for rustic or mountain settings, and in 1850 Downing recommended encaustic tile for "vestibules and entrance halls", says the National Park Service. A gentleman with opinions about the front hall as well as the roofline: I should have liked to be seated beside him at dinner.

Her dates are gently disputed. Pennsylvania gives 1830 to 1860, while several local guides give 1840 to 1880\. Pennsylvania calls the wooden Carpenter Gothic version rare in that state, and notes that the style later blended into High Victorian Gothic.

## The pointed arch is the proposal

Her must-see is the pointed arch, at a window, a door, a porch or a gable. Pennsylvania calls it the style's "most commonly identifiable feature". On simpler houses, Santa Barbara's guidelines allow a wooden cut-out that makes a window appear pointed. Without one or the other, I do not use her name, however steep her gables.

![The William J. Rotch Gothic Cottage, New Bedford, Massachusetts: a steep central gable with scrolled vergeboard and a finial, and pointed-arch windows](https://storage.ghost.io/c/da/52/da522df4-4ae9-4c3c-a003-00ccd4d61432/content/images/2026/11/gothic-revival-william-j-rotch-gothic-cottage-new-bedford-massachusetts.jpg)

The William J. Rotch Gothic Cottage, New Bedford, Massachusetts: a steep central gable with scrolled vergeboard and a finial, and pointed-arch windows. Photo: Magicpiano, CC BY-SA 4.0, [via Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:NewBedfordMA%5FRotchCottage%5FFront.jpg?ref=crestingchronicle.com)

Her companions are well worth finding: decorative vergeboards on steep front gables; finials or cross-bracing at the gable peaks; drip-moulded caps over the windows and doors; porches on turned posts; a steeply pitched roof and steep dormers; two-over-two or diamond-pane sash; bay windows; and, on high-style houses only, castle-like towers with parapets. I want her pointed arch plus at least two of these, one of them ornament: vergeboard, finials or cross-bracing, drip moulds, or porch trim. The name Carpenter Gothic also asks for vertical board-and-batten siding that I can see.

A drip mould, also called a hood mould or a label mould, is only ever a companion and never the proof, because Italianate, Second Empire and Tudor houses wear them too. Admire a hooded window by all means; just do not let it propose on the arch's behalf.

Her shapes vary. McAlester's field guide, in one of the few sentences of it my research could quote directly, says paired front gables appear in about 5 percent of American Gothic Revival houses. Santa Barbara's guidelines describe a centred gable, multiple or asymmetrical gables, and a front-gabled form. A fuller list of her forms exists only as a reconstruction from blogs and municipal summaries, so I keep to these.

![Roseland Cottage, built in 1846 in the Gothic Revival style, Woodstock, Connecticut](https://storage.ghost.io/c/da/52/da522df4-4ae9-4c3c-a003-00ccd4d61432/content/images/2026/11/photo-1907.jpg)

Roseland Cottage, built in 1846 in the Gothic Revival style, Woodstock, Connecticut. Photo: Carol M. Highsmith, public domain, [via Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Roseland%5FCottage%5Fwas%5Fbuilt%5Fin%5F1846%5Fin%5Fthe%5FGothic%5FRevival%5Fstyle%5Fas%5Fthe%5Fsummer%5Fhome%5Fof%5FHenry%5FChandler%5FBowen%5Fand%5Ffamily.%5FThe%5Fentire%5Fcomplex,%5Fwith%5Fa%5Fboxwood%5Fparterre%5Fgarden,%5Fan%5Ficehouse,%5Fgarden%5Fhouse,%5Fand%5FLCCN2011631587.jpg?ref=crestingchronicle.com)

## A flirtation is not a proposal

Now the caution that gives this curiosity its title. Pennsylvania notes that many vernacular buildings carry only a few Gothic touches, and the research behind my guide counts that as the main reason so many houses are over-labelled as Gothic. A pointed window in an otherwise plain building may be all she has, and then I must look at everything else about her before I decide what she is. Enjoy the Gothic touch, darling, and keep looking.

![The American Gothic House (Dibble House), Eldon, Iowa: a plain board-and-batten cottage with one pointed-arch window in her steep front gable](https://storage.ghost.io/c/da/52/da522df4-4ae9-4c3c-a003-00ccd4d61432/content/images/2026/11/carpenter-gothic-american-gothic-house-dibble-house-eldon-iowa.jpg)

The American Gothic House (Dibble House), Eldon, Iowa: a plain board-and-batten cottage with one pointed-arch window in her steep front gable. Photo: Original uploader was Jehjoyce at en.wikipedia, public domain, [via Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:2007-06-04-Gothic%5FHouse.jpg?ref=crestingchronicle.com)

## Her sisters and cousins

Two other ladies share her trim. The Swiss Chalet, Downing's other favourite, shows a projecting front gable with cut-out trim, a second-floor porch or balcony with a cut-out balustrade, patterned stickwork and a low roof with wide bracketed eaves. A low, wide-eaved gable with a cut-out balcony is the Chalet, and pointed openings are the Gothic. The Stick lady overlaps with both, but her mark is a grid of flat boards over clapboard.

![The Bullitt-Longenecker House, New Orleans, Louisiana, a Swiss Chalet: a wide front gable with deep bracketed eaves and a balcony set into the gable](https://storage.ghost.io/c/da/52/da522df4-4ae9-4c3c-a003-00ccd4d61432/content/images/2026/11/photo-2150.jpg)

The Bullitt-Longenecker House, New Orleans, Louisiana, a Swiss Chalet: a wide front gable with deep bracketed eaves and a balcony set into the gable. Photo: Jeffrey Beall, CC BY-SA 3.0, [via Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Bullitt-Longenecker%5FHouse.JPG?ref=crestingchronicle.com)

And the Folk Victorian can mimic her, especially a side-gabled house with an added centre gable. Pointed openings and vergeboards along the gable edges point to the Gothic; a regular rhythm of one-over-one windows with a spindle porch points to the Folk Victorian. That last comparison is my research's own reasoning, since no comparison by a state preservation office was found, so I hold it lightly.

## What she cannot lose

Her fatal losses: every pointed or hooded opening squared off and her vergeboard gone, or her roof pitch lowered. Lap siding laid over her board-and-batten takes away the Carpenter Gothic name, though she may still be a Gothic Revival. For the whole of her, see the [Gothic Revival style guide](https://www.crestingchronicle.com/gothic-revival-victorian-style/).

If a pointed arch has ever stopped you in a country lane, darling, I think we shall get along famously. Do join me: there is no fee, and every week I write to you with two of my favourite Victorians and my Wednesday Miscellany.

With a pattern book open on my lap,

![Lady Margaret Thornbury](https://storage.ghost.io/c/da/52/da522df4-4ae9-4c3c-a003-00ccd4d61432/content/images/2026/11/lady-margaret-thornbury-signature.png)

**Sources:** Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Gothic Revival; City of Santa Barbara, Gothic Revival design guidelines; Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Exotic Revival; National Park Service, Preservation Brief 40.