> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.crestingchronicle.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The Octagon House: Mr Fowler's Healthful Home, and How to Count Her Walls
- URL: https://www.crestingchronicle.com/octagon-house-history-how-to-identify/
- Published: 2026-11-08T16:43:39.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-17T21:54:31.000Z
- Description: In 1848 a gentleman promised that an eight-sided house would keep you well. The story of the Victorian Octagon, and how to tell a true one from a box with a bay window.
- Author: Lady Margaret Thornbury
- Tags: The Miscellany, Octagon, #tip-article

Dearest reader, of all my Victorian ladies, the Octagon is the only one who must be counted as well as admired. She owes her moment in society to a gentleman with a book and a theory, and her story is short, spirited and rather delightful.

## A gentleman with a theory

In 1848 Orson Squire Fowler published *The Octagon House: A House for All*, and in it he promoted the eight-sided house as healthful and economical. That is a great deal to promise from a floor plan. The Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, the state's preservation office, records the book and its claim, and I record them here with real affection. One so rarely meets an architect's argument made on behalf of one's health.

## A brief and spirited fashion

The fashion peaked between about 1850 and 1870, and few Octagons were built after 1865\. She was most common in the Northeast and the Midwest. Her whole season, then, lasted barely twenty years, and after 1865 very few new Octagons joined it. That brevity is exactly why I sit up straight when one appears in a listing: she is a rare guest, and rare guests are the ones everybody remembers.

Her dates matter to me in a practical way, too. Before I count a single wall, I ask a lady her year. My Victorian era runs from 1837 to about 1915, and an Octagon listed more than ten years outside her usual years, about 1850 to 1870, earns "appears to be" from me at most. A year built before 1920 is often an assessor's round-number estimate, besides, so I treat it as a hint and never as proof.

## The schoolhouses that are not on the guest list

A caution before you lose your heart to every eight-sided building in the countryside. Southeastern Pennsylvania has octagonal stone schoolhouses built by Quakers from the 1760s onward, and the survivors date from 1802 to 1841\. They belong to a separate and earlier tradition. However handsome their stonework, they are not Victorian Octagons, and however dear they are, they do not belong at this particular supper.

![The octagonal stone schoolhouse at Wrightstown, Bucks County, Pennsylvania, an earlier tradition than the Victorian Octagon](https://storage.ghost.io/c/da/52/da522df4-4ae9-4c3c-a003-00ccd4d61432/content/images/2026/11/photo-1871.jpg)

The octagonal stone schoolhouse at Wrightstown, Bucks County, Pennsylvania, an earlier tradition than the Victorian Octagon. Photo: Jack E. Boucher, Historic American Buildings Survey, public domain, [via Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Wrightstown%5FOctagonal%5FSchoolhouse%5FHABS%5FPhoto.jpg?ref=crestingchronicle.com)

## Why a photograph can fool you

Here is the trouble with meeting her in a listing. A photograph taken straight on can make an Octagon read as an ordinary box with a bay window on the front. So I never trust the front view alone. I hunt through the pictures for a side, corner or aerial view of the house itself, and then I count. An aerial photograph counts only when it shows her own walls clearly, never a wide view of the neighbourhood in which she is small or unclear.

Eight wall planes is her must-see. Without them I do not use her name at all, however promising the rest of her looks. A wall hidden behind a tree in one photograph may be counted from another photograph that shows it clearly, but a wall that is hidden in every view is never counted. I do not guess at walls, darling. I count the ones I can see.

![The Octagon House, Watertown, Wisconsin](https://storage.ghost.io/c/da/52/da522df4-4ae9-4c3c-a003-00ccd4d61432/content/images/2026/11/photo-1873.jpg)

The Octagon House, Watertown, Wisconsin. Photo: Iulus Ascanius at English Wikipedia, public domain, [via Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Octagon%5FHouse.JPG?ref=crestingchronicle.com)

## Her trim proves nothing; her companions confirm her

Her trim will not settle the question. The Pennsylvania commission notes that an Octagon's detail is often Greek Revival, Gothic Revival "and especially Italianate". She borrows her finery from other ladies' wardrobes, which is why only her plan can identify her. Against the [Italianate](https://www.crestingchronicle.com/italianate-victorian-style/), the lady she is most often taken for, the test never changes: count the wall planes.

Once her walls are counted, her companions are a pleasure to find: a low-pitched hipped roof, wide overhanging eaves, brackets at the cornice, a porch wrapping part or all of her and, on some examples, an octagonal cupola. I want her eight walls plus at least two of those features, and at least one of the two must be ornament: brackets at the cornice, or trim on her porch such as turned posts, sawn brackets, a spindle frieze, spandrels or decorative railings. A cupola or a wraparound porch is a delight, but neither one is ornament.

![The Rich-Twinn Octagon House, Akron, New York, seen from an angle so that several of her eight walls show](https://storage.ghost.io/c/da/52/da522df4-4ae9-4c3c-a003-00ccd4d61432/content/images/2026/11/octagon-rich-twinn-octagon-house-akron-new-york.jpg)

The Rich-Twinn Octagon House, Akron, New York, seen from an angle so that several of her eight walls show. Photo: Alyshkalia, CC0, [via Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Rich-Twinn%5FOctagon%5FHouse.jpg?ref=crestingchronicle.com)

## What undoes her

She must also keep most of her character. The National Register's Bulletin 15 judges a house by six qualities: her massing, the placing of her porches, bays and wings, her proportions, the pattern of her windows and doors, the texture of her walls and roof, and her ornament. I ask that at least four of the six still read as her style, with her ornament among them. Her one fatal loss is an addition that hides her eight walls, so that her plan can no longer be read. She is a rare lady, and I make no exception for her rarity.

For the whole of her wardrobe, laid out feature by feature, do visit the [Octagon style guide](https://www.crestingchronicle.com/octagon-victorian-style/).

If you would enjoy a curiosity like this one every Wednesday, darling, together with two of my favourite Victorian homes for sale each week, do join me. It costs nothing at all, and How to Spot a True Victorian arrives as a welcome present.

Counting walls by candlelight, as ever,

![Lady Margaret Thornbury](https://storage.ghost.io/c/da/52/da522df4-4ae9-4c3c-a003-00ccd4d61432/content/images/2026/11/lady-margaret-thornbury-signature.png)

**Sources:** Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Octagon; National Register Bulletin 15.