Is It Victorian? Lady Margaret's Field Guide

How to tell a Queen Anne from an Italianate, a Second Empire from a mere mansard, and a true Victorian from a charming impostor.

Edward J. Jenkins House, a Queen Anne Free Classic Victorian house in Bryan, Texas: queen Anne asymmetry with a domed corner tower and shingled gables, but the wraparound veranda rests on cl
Edward J. Jenkins House, Bryan, Texas

Dearest reader, a confession: a great many houses advertised as "Victorian" are nothing of the sort, and a great many true Victorians are passed over because they do not wear a turret.

Victorian is not one style but an entire era, roughly 1837 to 1910, and within it live a dozen distinct families. To tell them apart, one must read a house the way one reads a guest at a ball: the roof first, then the shape, then the walls, and the trim last of all. Brackets, spindles and gingerbread are accessories. Everyone wears them, so on their own they prove nothing.

Allow me to make the introductions.

In this guide:

Gothic Revival and Carpenter Gothic

The eldest of the family, about the 1840s to the 1860s.

Roseland Cottage (Henry C. Bowen House), a Carpenter Gothic Victorian house in Woodstock, Connecticut: steep cross gables trimmed with lacy sawn vergeboards and finials, board-and-batten walls, and pointed-arch Gothic openings on the porch
Roseland Cottage (Henry C. Bowen House), Woodstock, Connecticut
American Gothic House (Dibble House), a Carpenter Gothic Victorian house in Eldon, Iowa: a plain board-and-batten cottage whose steep front gable holds a single pointed-arch Gothic window, the defining Carpenter Gothic gesture
American Gothic House (Dibble House), Eldon, Iowa
William J. Rotch Gothic Cottage, a Gothic Revival Victorian house in New Bedford, Massachusetts: very steep central gable edged with deep scrolled vergeboard and a finial, pointed-arch windows, and a lancet-arched entry
William J. Rotch Gothic Cottage, New Bedford, Massachusetts

How to know her: Look for a steeply pitched gable trimmed with lacy vergeboard, and windows with pointed arches or drip-mold hoods above them. Finials often crown the peaks. Her country cousin, Carpenter Gothic, dresses in vertical board-and-batten siding.

Do not confuse her with: A farmhouse with a decorated gable. Without pointed or hooded windows, I'm afraid she is not Gothic at all.

Italianate

About 1840 to 1885, beloved in the Midwest and on Main Street.

Victoria Mansion (Morse-Libby House), an Italian Villa Victorian house in Portland, Maine: asymmetrical brownstone villa with a square entrance tower, low-pitched roofs, heavily bracketed cornices, and round-arched windows
Victoria Mansion (Morse-Libby House), Portland, Maine
Ulysses S. Grant Home, an Italianate Victorian house in Galena, Illinois: two-story brick box under a low hipped roof with very wide overhanging eaves carried on paired brackets, plus a small columned entry porch
Ulysses S. Grant Home, Galena, Illinois
Mary Darwin House, an Italianate Victorian house in Burlington, Iowa: cubic brick house with a low hipped roof and broad eaves lined with large paired scroll brackets, and tall narrow windows with heavy hoods
Mary Darwin House, Burlington, Iowa

How to know her: Look up at the eaves. A low-pitched roof sails out wide over the walls, held up by brackets, very often in pairs. The windows are tall and narrow, with arched or heavily crowned tops. Some wear a cupola or a square tower; the towered version is called an Italian Villa.

Do not confuse her with: Second Empire. If the main roof is a mansard, she is French, not Italian.

Second Empire

About 1855 to 1885, a favourite of the Northeast and Midwest.

Grenville M. Dodge House, a Second Empire Victorian house in Council Bluffs, Iowa: a tall mansard roof with ornate dormers caps the whole main block, above a bracketed cornice and hooded windows
Grenville M. Dodge House, Council Bluffs, Iowa
Morris-Butler House, a Second Empire Victorian house in Indianapolis, Indiana: brick house whose main block and tall corner tower are both capped by straight-sided mansard roofs pierced by dormers
Morris-Butler House, Indianapolis, Indiana
Harvey M. Vaile Mansion, a Second Empire Victorian house in Independence, Missouri: symmetrical brick mansion entirely capped by a patterned slate mansard with dormers, rising to a central mansard-roofed tower with iron cresting
Harvey M. Vaile Mansion, Independence, Missouri

How to know her: One feature decides it: a mansard roof, steep on the sides with dormer windows set into it and nearly flat on top, covering the main body of the house. Iron cresting along the top is a delightful bonus.

Do not confuse her with: A house with a mansard only on its tower. The mansard must crown the whole house. And do be aware that owners sometimes added a mansard to an older house later, which no photograph can reveal.

Shall I send the season's finest Victorians straight to you? New listings and my honest verdicts. Turrets, towers and trim, never a tract home in disguise.

Subscribe free

Octagon

The 1850s and 1860s, a brief and spirited fashion.

John Richards Octagon House (Octagon House Museum), an Octagon Victorian house in Watertown, Wisconsin: several of the eight flat brick wall planes are visible, wrapped by two tiers of encircling verandas and topped by a low roof with a cupola
John Richards Octagon House (Octagon House Museum), Watertown, Wisconsin
Rich-Twinn Octagon House, an Octagon Victorian house in Akron, New York: two-storey octagon seen from an angle so several of the eight wall planes show, with a low hipped roof, wide eaves on paired scroll brackets and a wraparound veranda. It does carry a small octagonal cupola, but no dome or exotic ornament
Rich-Twinn Octagon House, Akron, New York
Loren Andrus Octagon House (Washington Octagon House), an Octagon Victorian house in Washington Township, Michigan: brick octagon viewed corner-on with five wall planes visible, low hipped roof, wide eaves on large paired scroll brackets and a columned veranda; a plain octagonal cupola on top
Loren Andrus Octagon House (Washington Octagon House), Washington Township, Michigan

How to know her: Count the walls: eight. She usually wears Italianate trim, a low roof with bracketed eaves, a porch wrapped about her, and often a little cupola on top.

Do not confuse her with: An Italianate with a bay window. From straight ahead she can look like a box, so do step to one side and count.

Exotic Revivals

Rare and adventurous.

Villa Zorayda (Zorayda Castle), a Moorish Victorian house in St. Augustine, Florida: poured-concrete walls with crenellated parapets, horseshoe and multifoil Moorish arches, and brightly painted Alhambra-style window surrounds
Villa Zorayda (Zorayda Castle), St. Augustine, Florida
Olana (Frederic Edwin Church house), a Moorish / Persian Victorian house in Greenport (near Hudson), New York: polychrome brick and stone villa with pointed Moorish arches, a tower with patterned tile and stencilled decoration, and Persian-style ornament
Olana (Frederic Edwin Church house), Greenport (near Hudson), New York
Bullitt-Longenecker House, a Swiss Chalet Victorian house in 3627 Carondelet Street, New Orleans, Louisiana: low, very wide front gable with deep projecting eaves on big brackets, sawn bargeboard along the rake, a central balcony set into the gable and applied diagonal board patterns on the walls. Photo taken 2003; a tree branch crosses the upper left of the gable
Bullitt-Longenecker House, 3627 Carondelet Street, New Orleans, Louisiana

How to know her: Name the foreign motif or do not use the label. Moorish houses show ogee arches, onion domes and patterned tile. Swiss Chalets show a front gable with cut-out wooden trim and a balcony. Egyptian houses show a rolled cornice and windows that narrow toward the top.

Do not confuse her with: Any house with fancy brackets. Brackets alone do not make one exotic, merely well dressed.

Stick

About the 1860s to the 1890s, chiefly the Northeast and the San Francisco Bay.

Emlen Physick Estate, a Stick Victorian house in Cape May, New Jersey: clapboard walls divided into panels by flat vertical, horizontal and diagonal boards, with steep gables, jerkinhead dormers, and heavy porch braces
Emlen Physick Estate, Cape May, New Jersey
John N. A. Griswold House (Newport Art Museum), a Stick Victorian house in Newport, Rhode Island: walls gridded into panels by exposed flat stickwork, steep cross gables, and a porch carried on diagonal braced posts
John N. A. Griswold House (Newport Art Museum), Newport, Rhode Island
Alfred Earnshaw House (historic photograph), a Stick Victorian house in Riverton, New Jersey: period photo showing walls divided into panels by flat trim boards, steep gables and a hip-roofed tower, with the original braced wraparound porch
Alfred Earnshaw House (historic photograph), Riverton, New Jersey

How to know her: Look at the walls. Flat boards are laid over the siding to divide it into panels, like picture frames, with diagonal braces and decorative trusses in the steep gables. She is all angles and verticals.

Do not confuse her with: Queen Anne. Stick is grids and straight lines; Queen Anne is towers, curves and a mixture of textures.

Queen Anne

The belle of the ball, about 1880 to 1910, found in every corner of the country.

Edward J. Jenkins House, a Queen Anne Free Classic Victorian house in Bryan, Texas: queen Anne asymmetry with a domed corner tower and shingled gables, but the wraparound veranda rests on classical columns rather than turned spindles
Edward J. Jenkins House, Bryan, Texas (Free Classic)
John and Anna O'Brien House (Rivertown Inn), a Queen Anne Free Classic Victorian house in Stillwater, Minnesota: asymmetrical gabled house with patterned shingles in the gable, and a porch with a classical pediment over the entry carried on round columns
John and Anna O'Brien House (Rivertown Inn), Stillwater, Minnesota (Free Classic)
David and M. Maria Hughes House, a Queen Anne Free Classic Victorian house in Williamsburg, Iowa: asymmetrical massing with a corner tower, steep cross gables and dormers, and a wraparound porch carried on round classical columns set on rock-faced stone piers, with a pedimented porch gable
David and M. Maria Hughes House, Williamsburg, Iowa (Free Classic)
William Watts Sherman House, a Queen Anne Half-timbered Victorian house in Newport, Rhode Island: mixed wall textures stacked floor by floor: rough stone ground story, a band of half-timbered gables with leaded windows, and shingled upper walls under steep roofs
William Watts Sherman House, Newport, Rhode Island (Half-timbered)
Mylius-Eaton House, a Queen Anne Half-timbered Victorian house in 2900 Jackson Street, Sioux City, Iowa: three steep cross gables filled with half-timbering above a wood body (clapboard first floor, shingled second floor), irregular massing and a full-width porch. Half-timbering is confined to the gables
Mylius-Eaton House, 2900 Jackson Street, Sioux City, Iowa (Half-timbered)
Kildare-McCormick House, a Queen Anne Patterned Masonry Victorian house in 2005 Kildare Street, Huntsville, Alabama: masonry Queen Anne with a round corner tower and conical roof, limestone walls with contrasting red brick quoins and window surrounds, a terra cotta relief in the bay gable, and river-stone panels in the upper walls; asymmetrical massing. Large evergreen shrubs hide the lower right corner
Kildare-McCormick House, 2005 Kildare Street, Huntsville, Alabama (Patterned Masonry)
Carson Mansion, a Queen Anne Spindlework Victorian house in Eureka, California: wildly asymmetrical massing with a tall tower, many gables, and porches and balconies laden with turned spindles, beads, and mixed shingle and board textures
Carson Mansion, Eureka, California (Spindlework)
Hale House, a Queen Anne Spindlework Victorian house in Los Angeles, California (now at Heritage Square Museum): asymmetrical facade with a round corner turret, fish-scale shingles against clapboard and incised panels, and a porch with turned posts and spindle trim
Hale House, Los Angeles, California (now at Heritage Square Museum) (Spindlework)
House in Pendleton Heights (name not recorded), a Queen Anne Spindlework Victorian house in Kansas City, Missouri: three-story corner turret with fish-scale shingles and conical roof, cross gables, and a wraparound porch with a turned spindlework frieze
House in Pendleton Heights (name not recorded), Kansas City, Missouri (Spindlework)

How to know her: An asymmetrical front, a steep and irregular roof with cross gables, and walls that mix their textures: clapboard here, fish-scale shingles there, a panel or two besides. Very often a round or many-sided corner tower and a sweeping wraparound porch. She has four favourite gowns: Spindlework (turned posts and lacy spindle friezes), Free Classic (classical columns and Palladian windows), Half-timbered (timbering in the gables) and Patterned Masonry (brick or stone with little wooden trim).

Do not confuse her with: Colonial Revival, because she sometimes wears columns. About a third of Queen Annes do, so columns never disqualify her; it is her asymmetrical shape that tells. And Folk Victorian: strip away the trim in your mind, and if a plain farmhouse remains, she is Folk.

Dearest reader, the best houses are spoken for quickly. Subscribe and I shall write to you every week with two of my favourite Victorians for sale, and my Inner Circle meets each new arrival first.

Join the Chronicle

Shingle

About 1880 to 1910, born on the New England coast.

Isaac Bell House (Edna Villa), a Shingle Victorian house in Newport, Rhode Island: continuous wood-shingle skin wraps walls, gables and the round corner tower without corner boards, over a brick base and broad porch
Isaac Bell House (Edna Villa), Newport, Rhode Island
Kragsyde (George Nixon Black house, demolished 1929), a Shingle Victorian house in Manchester-by-the-Sea, Massachusetts: period photo showing a sprawling house sheathed entirely in shingles, with a broad shingled arch spanning the drive on a rubble-stone base
Kragsyde (George Nixon Black house, demolished 1929), Manchester-by-the-Sea, Massachusetts
Mary Fiske Stoughton House, a Shingle Victorian house in Cambridge, Massachusetts: uninterrupted shingle cladding flows over the walls and a round stair tower, with a low broad roof and ribbon windows
Mary Fiske Stoughton House, Cambridge, Massachusetts

How to know her: Wooden shingles wrap the walls and roof like a single cloak, with the eaves held tight to the walls. She is long, low and horizontal, sparing with ornament, and often sits on a stone base under a broad or gambrel roof.

Do not confuse her with: Queen Anne. A Queen Anne uses shingles as one patch among several materials; a Shingle house wears nothing else.

Richardsonian Romanesque

About the 1870s to 1900, named for the architect H. H. Richardson.

Samuel Cupples House, a Richardsonian Romanesque Victorian house in St. Louis, Missouri: rock-faced pink granite and sandstone walls, round towers with conical roofs, and a porch of wide, low round arches on short columns
Samuel Cupples House, St. Louis, Missouri
Christian Heurich Mansion (Heurich House Museum), a Richardsonian Romanesque Victorian house in Washington, D.C.: heavy rough-cut brownstone, a round corner tower with a conical roof, and a deep entrance porch of broad round arches
Christian Heurich Mansion (Heurich House Museum), Washington, D.C.
H. Alden Smith House, a Richardsonian Romanesque Victorian house in 1400 Harmon Place, Minneapolis, Minnesota: whole exterior of a rough-faced red sandstone mansion with a round corner tower, round-arched windows in groups and a broad round-arched opening beside the entrance porch. A temporary sign board stands on the lawn in front
H. Alden Smith House, 1400 Harmon Place, Minneapolis, Minnesota

How to know her: Heavy rough-faced stone, wide round arches over doors and windows, squat columns, deep-set windows and round towers built right into the walls. She is grand, solid and quite immovable.

Do not confuse her with: Nothing in wood. A wooden house is never Romanesque, however many arches she attempts.

Folk Victorian

About 1870 to 1910, when the railroad brought factory-made trim to every town.

Folk Victorian house (name not recorded) in Elgin, Texas: plain one-story side-gabled folk body under a metal roof, dressed up with a full-width porch of turned posts and sawn brackets
Folk Victorian house (name not recorded), Elgin, Texas
Walter E. Moore House, a Folk Victorian house in Webster, North Carolina: simple 1.5-story frame house with a central gabled wall dormer, given a porch with turned posts and sawn brackets
Walter E. Moore House, Webster, North Carolina
Col. Ralph Andrews House, a Folk Victorian house in 517 W. Center Street, Beebe, Arkansas: plain clapboard two-storey house with side-gabled main block and a front gable, fronted by a full-width porch and a second-storey balcony, both with turned posts, a spindle frieze and jigsawn brackets clearly visible. An overhead utility line crosses the upper storey
Col. Ralph Andrews House, 517 W. Center Street, Beebe, Arkansas

How to know her: A simple farmhouse shape (a front gable, an L-shape, a tall I-house or a pyramid roof) dressed up with turned spindles and jigsaw-cut brackets, mostly on the porch. No tower, no bays, no mixture of wall textures.

Do not confuse her with: Queen Anne. And note that porches were sometimes added to older plain houses later, so she is judged by how she looks today, not by when she was built.

Not Victorian, Darling

And now, the charming houses who were simply not invited to this particular ball. They are lovely in their own right, but they are not Victorian, and I shan't pretend otherwise.

University House (Eastern Washington University), a Colonial Revival house (not a Victorian) in Cheney, Washington: whole house in one view: a symmetrical two-storey brick front under a low hipped roof with a dentilled cornice, a centred semicircular entrance portico on fluted classical columns with an iron balcony above, and multi-pane sash windows set evenly on either side
University House (Eastern Washington University), Cheney, Washington
John Hultquist House, an American Foursquare house (not a Victorian) in Swedesburg, Iowa: boxy two-story cube under a low hipped roof with a single hipped dormer and a full-width porch on square columns
John Hultquist House, Swedesburg, Iowa
Benjamin Hamilton House, a Craftsman bungalow (not a Victorian) in Bend, Oregon: whole house straight on: a low-pitched front gable with wide overhanging eaves held by triangular knee-brace brackets, over a full-width porch whose tapered square columns stand on rough stone piers, with a brick chimney on the side
Benjamin Hamilton House, Bend, Oregon
Tudor Revival house in Eastmoreland in Portland, Oregon (not a Victorian): whole house straight on: three steep, nested front gables with dark half-timbering over stucco, a brick ground floor, leaded diamond-pane casement windows and a side chimney
Tudor Revival house in Eastmoreland, Portland, Oregon
  • Colonial Revival: A symmetrical front, a pedimented doorway, columns and shutters, all very orderly.
  • American Foursquare: A two-story square box with a low hipped roof, a dormer in the middle and a broad porch.
  • Craftsman bungalow: A low roof with the rafter tails showing under the eaves, and thick tapered columns on brick or stone piers.
  • Tudor Revival: Steep front gables, half-timbering over stucco or brick, and a great chimney.

Do beware the Victorian-style new build as well: an attached front garage, plastic trim and snap-in window grids give her away at once.

Lady Margaret's Quick Checklist

  1. The roof: mansard, low and bracketed, steep and gabled, or a shingled cloak?
  2. The shape: symmetrical or asymmetrical, a plain box or a tower and bays?
  3. The walls: one material, framed panels, or a mixture of textures?
  4. The trim, last of all, to confirm what the roof has already told you.
  5. And mind the year built: before 1920 it is very often an assessor's guess.
  6. "Painted Lady" describes the paint, darling, not the style. "Eastlake" is a kind of trim, not a style either.

Now you know what I know. Do write to me if you spot a beauty.

Yours in cresting and cornices,
Lady Margaret Thornbury

Now that you can tell a Queen Anne from an impostor, let me find you the real thing.

Get Victorian listings by email

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes a house Victorian?

Victorian describes an era, not one style: houses built in the styles popular from about 1837 to 1910, including Gothic Revival, Italianate, Second Empire, Stick, Queen Anne, Shingle, Richardsonian Romanesque and Folk Victorian. Each style is identified by its roof, shape and walls first, and by its trim last.

What is the most common Victorian house style?

Queen Anne. It was the most popular American house style from about 1880 to 1900 and is found in every region. Look for an asymmetrical front, a steep roof with cross gables and walls that mix textures, often with a corner tower.

Is every old house with gingerbread trim Victorian?

No. Brackets, spindles and gingerbread appear on many styles and were added to plain houses too. A simple farmhouse shape dressed with factory-made trim is Folk Victorian, and some trim was added long after the house was built.

What is the difference between Italianate and Second Empire?

The roof. Second Empire has a mansard roof, steep and dormered, over the main body of the house. Italianate has a low-pitched roof with wide bracketed eaves. A mansard on a tower alone does not make a house Second Empire.

Is a Painted Lady a style of house?

No. Painted Lady describes a Victorian or Edwardian house painted in three or more colours, a term made popular by a 1978 book about San Francisco. The house underneath may be Italianate, Stick or Queen Anne.

What is Eastlake on a Victorian house?

Eastlake is a kind of ornament, not a house style: chunky, incised and knob-and-spindle trim named after the English designer Charles Eastlake. It appears on Stick and Queen Anne houses.

How can you tell a Folk Victorian from a Queen Anne?

Imagine the trim removed. If a plain farmhouse shape remains, such as a front gable, an L-shape or an I-house, it is Folk Victorian. A Queen Anne has an asymmetrical shape, mixed wall textures and often a tower or bay windows.

Is the year built on a listing reliable for old houses?

Not always. For houses built before about 1920, the year built in assessor and listing records is often an estimate, frequently a round number like 1890 or 1900. The architecture tells you more than the date.

Photo credits