The Octagon House: How to Identify the Victorian Who Would Not Be Square

Count the walls, dearest reader: eight. How to recognise a Victorian Octagon house, and why her Italianate trim must never fool you.

Share
Loren Andrus Octagon House, an Octagon Victorian house in Washington Township, Michigan: a brick octagon seen corner-on, with bracketed eaves, a porch and a cupola
Loren Andrus Octagon House, Washington Township, Michigan, 1860: five of her brick walls in view, wide eaves on large paired brackets, a columned porch and a cupola.

An Octagon house is the Victorian lady with eight walls, and the only one who must be counted as well as admired.

Dearest reader, she was a brief and spirited fashion, championed by an 1848 book that promised she was healthful and economical. She usually borrows her trim from the Italianate lady, so it is her plan, not her frills, that tells you who she is.

In this guide:

How to Spot Her: The Octagon Must-See and Features

First, her year

Before I count a single wall, I ask her year. My Victorians were built between 1837 and about 1915. A listing before 1830 or after 1925 never reaches me, and one listed between 1916 and 1925 must show her age in her roof, walls and trim before I call her Victorian, and gets no style name outright. Before 1920 the listed year is often an assessor's guess, so it is a hint and nothing more.

The Octagon's usual years are about 1850 to 1870. A listing more than ten years outside them earns "appears to be" at most.

The must-see: eight walls

Her must-see is eight wall planes, each flat face meeting the next at an angle. Seeing them usually needs a side, angled or aerial photograph of the house itself. From straight ahead she can look like a box with a bay window. An aerial counts only when it shows her own walls clearly, never a wide view in which she is small. The Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission is clear that her plan is what identifies her.

Rich-Twinn Octagon House with numbered circles on its wall planes, eave brackets, cupola, turned porch posts and wraparound porch
Rich-Twinn Octagon House, Akron, New York, 1849. The numbers match the list below.
  1. 1Her wall planes, each flat face meeting the next at an angle: the must-see. Several of her eight show from this corner.
  2. 2Brackets under the wide eaves (ornament).
  3. 3An octagonal cupola.
  4. 4Turned porch posts (ornament).
  5. 5A porch wrapping around her.

The features that count

With her walls counted, these confirm her. Each must be clearly visible on her own outside:

  • A low-pitched hipped roof.
  • Wide overhanging eaves.
  • Brackets at the cornice.
  • A porch wrapping part or all of her.
  • An octagonal cupola, on some.
  • Porch trim: turned posts, sawn brackets, a spindle frieze or spandrels, or decorative railings.
an octagonal cupola with bracketed eaves
An example of an octagonal cupola with bracketed eaves: Rich-Twinn Octagon House, Akron, New York
A cornice lined with pairs of scrolled wooden brackets, evenly spaced along the eaves above shuttered windows
An example of brackets at the cornice: Isaac Kinsey House, Milton, Indiana
A square porch post flanked by a pair of flat, cut-out wooden brackets in scroll and star shapes under the porch beam
An example of sawn porch brackets: Kamehameha V Summer House, Moanalua Gardens, Honolulu, Hawaii
A porch frieze of round wooden balls strung on thin spindles, set between sawn brackets above a curved arch, under a fish-scale shingled roof edge
An example of a spindle frieze on a porch: John E. G. Povey House, Portland, Oregon

Three features, at the very least

Three things, darling, before I say her name. She needs her eight walls plus at least two more features from that list, and at least one of them must be ornament: brackets at the cornice, or trim on her porch. A cupola or a wraparound porch is a fine thing, but neither is ornament.

She must also keep most of her character. The National Register judges a house by six qualities: her massing, where her porches and bays sit, her proportions, the pattern of her windows and doors, the texture of her walls and roof, and her ornament. I want at least four of the six still reading as her style, and her ornament must be one of the four (National Register Bulletin 15, p. 46).

What rules her out

A rectangular plan with a bay window on the front. However many brackets she wears, a box is not an octagon.

Her fatal losses

Additions that hide her eight walls, so that her plan can no longer be read. She is a rare lady, and I make no exceptions for her rarity.

Only her own outside

Only her own outside counts: never a neighbour, never a street view or an aerial in which she is small or unclear, never her interiors, never the listing's words about her style. A wall plane hidden behind a tree is not counted until another photograph shows it.

Shall I send the season's finest Victorians straight to you? New listings and my honest verdicts. Turrets, towers and trim, never a tract home in disguise.

Subscribe free

Octagon Dates and Where She Lives

Her peak ran from 1850 to 1870, with few built after 1865, says the Pennsylvania commission. She is most common in the Northeast and the Midwest.

She owes her moment to Orson Squire Fowler's 1848 book, The Octagon House: A House for All, which praised her as healthful and economical. Her detail is often Greek Revival or Gothic Revival, and especially Italianate. Pennsylvania's octagonal stone schoolhouses, built by Quakers from the 1760s, are an older and separate tradition, not our Victorian lady.

Do Not Confuse Her With...

John Richards Octagon House (Octagon House Museum), an Octagon Victorian house in Watertown, Wisconsin: several of the eight flat brick wall planes are visible, wrapped by two tiers of encircling verandas and topped by a low roof with a cupola
OctagonSeveral flat brick wall planes meeting at angles, wrapped by two tiers of verandas. John Richards Octagon House, Watertown, Wisconsin.
Ulysses S. Grant Home, an Italianate Victorian house in Galena, Illinois: two-story brick box under a low hipped roof with very wide overhanging eaves carried on paired brackets, plus a small columned entry porch
ItalianateItalianate brackets and eaves, but four walls to a rectangular block. Ulysses S. Grant Home, Galena, Illinois.

Italianate. The Octagon usually wears Italianate brackets and eaves, so the trim proves nothing. Count the wall planes: eight, and she is an Octagon; four, and she is not.

A box with a bay window. From straight ahead a bay can pass for three faces of an octagon, so do step to one side and look again before you count.

Dearest reader, the best houses are spoken for quickly. Subscribe and I shall write to you the moment a worthy Victorian comes to market.

Join the Chronicle

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an Octagon house?

A house built on an eight-sided plan, with eight wall planes. Look also for a low hipped roof, wide bracketed eaves, a porch wrapping part or all of the house, and on some, an octagonal cupola.

When were Octagon houses built?

Their peak ran from 1850 to 1870, with few built after 1865, according to the Pennsylvania state preservation office.

Is an Octagon house a Victorian?

Yes. The Octagon is a Victorian-era house type of the 1850s and 1860s. She still needs her eight walls plus two more Octagon features, one of them ornament, on her own outside.

How can you tell an Octagon from an Italianate house?

Count the walls. Octagons usually wear Italianate trim, so only the plan decides, and a side or angled photograph is usually needed to see it.

Why were Octagon houses built?

They were popularised by Orson Squire Fowler's 1848 book, The Octagon House: A House for All, which promoted the shape as healthful and economical.

See every style side by side in Lady Margaret's Field Guide.

Photo credits