The Exotic Revival Victorian: How to Identify the Well-Travelled Guest

Egyptian, Moorish or Swiss Chalet: how to recognise an Exotic Revival house by her imported motif, and why fancy brackets alone never qualify.

Share
Olana, a Moorish Revival house near Hudson, New York: polychrome brick and stone, pointed Moorish arches and a tower with a patterned tile roof
Olana, the painter Frederic Edwin Church's house near Hudson, New York, 1870 to 1872: polychrome brick and stone, pointed Moorish arches and a patterned tile tower.

An Exotic Revival house is the Victorian lady who has travelled: she wears a named foreign motif, Egyptian, Moorish or Swiss Chalet, and without it she has no claim to the title.

Dearest reader, she is rare and adventurous, and I name her only when I can name her motif. Fancy brackets alone make a lady well dressed, not exotic.

In this guide:

How to Spot Her: The Exotic Revival Must-See and Features

First, her year

Her year comes first, and for this lady it matters doubly. My Victorians were built between 1837 and about 1915; a listing before 1830 or after 1925 is turned away, and one between 1916 and 1925 must prove her age in her roof, walls and trim and never gets a style name outright. Before 1920 a listed year is often an assessor's guess, so it is a hint, never proof.

Egyptian and Moorish houses came back into fashion in the 1920s and 1930s, so an exotic lady's date must not place her in that later revival. If it does, I do not name her Exotic Revival, however splendid her arches.

The must-see: one named imported motif

Her must-see is one named imported motif, clearly visible on her own outside. The Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission describes three:

  • Egyptian: a rolled cavetto cornice, window surrounds that narrow toward the top, columns like bundled reeds, the vulture and winged sun disk.
  • Moorish: ogee arches, an onion dome or minaret, recessed porches, mosaic tile trim, and complex, intricate details with a Middle Eastern or Moorish theme, such as the horseshoe arches, Arabic lettering, carved latticework and decorated parapets that the National Register record for Villa Zorayda describes. Mosaic means a pattern built from many small pieces; a band of larger tiles, each painted with its own design, is not mosaic, though it is still Moorish detail.
  • Swiss Chalet: a low, wide-eaved front gable with cut-out trim, a second-floor porch or balcony with a cut-out balustrade, and patterned stickwork.

Generic brackets or spindles are never enough.

Villa Zorayda with numbered circles on its lobed Moorish arches, recessed arcaded porch and band of patterned tiles
Villa Zorayda, St. Augustine, Florida, 1883: a Moorish lady in poured concrete. She shows her motif plus two more features from the Moorish list. The numbers match the list below.
  1. 1Lobed, pointed Moorish arches on the upper loggia: a detail with a Middle Eastern or Moorish theme, and her must-see motif.
  2. 2A recessed, arcaded porch: on the Moorish list.
  3. 3A band of patterned tiles above the lower arcade. Each tile carries its own star or rosette, so it is not mosaic, but it is Moorish detail all the same.

The features that count

The features that count are the other items on her own sub-style's list above. A Moorish lady proves herself with more Moorish detail, a chalet with more chalet detail. Mixing lists does not count.

cusped Moorish arches on a loggia
An example of cusped Moorish arches on a loggia: Villa Zorayda (Zorayda Castle), St. Augustine, Florida
a Moorish doorway between slender columns, under a carved panel of Arabic lettering
An example of a Moorish doorway between slender columns, under a carved panel of Arabic lettering: Villa Zorayda (Zorayda Castle), St. Augustine, Florida
pointed arches and a patterned tile roof on a tower
An example of pointed arches and a patterned tile roof on a tower: Olana (Frederic Edwin Church house), Greenport (near Hudson), New York
a low chalet gable with cut-out trim over a balcony with a cut-out balustrade
An example of a low chalet gable with cut-out trim over a balcony with a cut-out balustrade: Parsons-Abbott-Mosser House, Huntington, West Virginia

Three features, at the very least

Three things, darling. She needs her motif plus at least two more features from the same sub-style's list, and her date must not conflict.

She must also keep most of her character. The National Register judges a house by six qualities: her massing, where her porches and bays sit, her proportions, the pattern of her windows and doors, the texture of her walls and roof, and her ornament. I want at least four of the six still reading as her style, and her ornament must be one of the four (National Register Bulletin 15, p. 46).

Her fatal losses

The motif gone, for example a chalet's cut-out balcony removed. Without it she is simply a house with good taste in travel.

Only her own outside

Only her own outside counts: never the neighbour's dome, never a street view or an aerial in which she is small or unclear, never her interiors, never the listing's words about her style. A motif half hidden by palms is not counted until another photograph shows it clearly.

Shall I send the season's finest Victorians straight to you? New listings and my honest verdicts. Turrets, towers and trim, never a tract home in disguise.

Subscribe free

Exotic Revival Dates and Where She Lives

Her dates are contested. The Pennsylvania commission gives two periods, about 1830 to 1850 and 1920 to 1930, and calls all three sub-styles rare in Pennsylvania. McAlester, as cited by a library blog, gives 1835 to 1890 and treats the three as one movement of ornament applied to houses of the Romantic era.

Egyptian work was mostly public: banks, prisons, courthouses and cemeteries, applied to bodies that are otherwise Greek Revival or Italianate. The Swiss Chalet was promoted in Andrew Jackson Downing's pattern books for rustic and mountain settings. She is rare wherever you look, which is precisely her charm.

Do Not Confuse Her With...

Parsons-Abbott-Mosser House, a Swiss Chalet Victorian house in Huntington, West Virginia: a low, wide-eaved front gable over the two-storey entrance bay, its face filled with pierced cut-out boards and its eaves crested with sawn ornaments, over a second-floor balcony with a cut-out balustrade; the full-width porch below has cut-out railings too. Paint is peeling, scaffolding stands at the left end and a wire crosses the gable
Exotic Revival (Swiss Chalet)Built in 1870. A low, wide-eaved front gable trimmed with cut-out boards sits over a second-floor balcony with a cut-out balustrade: the chalet's own combination. Parsons-Abbott-Mosser House, Huntington, West Virginia.
Emlen Physick Estate, a Stick Victorian house in Cape May, New Jersey: clapboard walls divided into panels by flat vertical, horizontal and diagonal boards, with steep gables, jerkinhead dormers, and heavy porch braces
StickFlat boards divide her clapboard walls into panels, under steep gables. Emlen Physick Estate, Cape May, New Jersey.

Stick and Carpenter Gothic. Stickwork and cut-out trim appear on all three. The low, wide-eaved gable with a cut-out balcony is the chalet's own combination; a grid of flat boards over clapboard walls means Stick; pointed openings mean Gothic.

Greek Revival or Italianate, for the Egyptian lady. Egyptian ornament is applied to those bodies, so look for the cavetto cornice, the narrowing window surrounds, the bundled-reed columns or the winged disk.

Any house with fancy brackets. Brackets are worn by nearly everyone at this ball, and prove nothing about where a lady has been.

Dearest reader, the best houses are spoken for quickly. Subscribe and I shall write to you the moment a worthy Victorian comes to market.

Join the Chronicle

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an Exotic Revival house?

A Victorian-era house dressed in a named imported motif: Egyptian, Moorish or Swiss Chalet. She needs the motif plus two more features from the same sub-style's list.

What are the Exotic Revival styles?

Egyptian (cavetto cornices, window surrounds narrowing upward, bundled-reed columns, the winged sun disk), Moorish (ogee arches, onion domes or minarets, recessed porches, mosaic tile trim, and other intricate details with a Middle Eastern or Moorish theme, such as horseshoe arches or patterned tile) and Swiss Chalet (a low wide-eaved front gable with cut-out trim, a cut-out balcony and patterned stickwork).

How do you tell a Swiss Chalet from a Stick house?

Both use stickwork and cut-out trim. A low, wide-eaved front gable with a cut-out balcony is the chalet; a grid of flat boards dividing clapboard walls into panels is Stick.

When were Exotic Revival houses built?

Sources disagree: about 1830 to 1850 and again 1920 to 1930 according to the Pennsylvania state preservation office, or 1835 to 1890 according to McAlester as cited by a library blog.

Is a Moorish-style house from the 1920s Victorian?

No. Egyptian and Moorish styles were revived in the 1920s and 1930s, after the Victorian era, so a house from those years is not Victorian, however exotic.

See every style side by side in Lady Margaret's Field Guide.

Photo credits